MLS Narrows Search for Don Garber Successor to Three Finalists

The Search for the Next MLS Commissioner

Major League Soccer is approaching a pivotal turning point in its history. After decades of steady growth under the leadership of Commissioner Don Garber, the league has officially narrowed its search for his successor to a final trio of candidates. According to industry insiders, the list has been refined to three prominent figures: LAFC co-owner Larry Berg, 49ers Enterprises president Paraag Marathe, and former Fox executive David Nathanson.

This transition comes at a critical juncture for the sport in North America. With the 2026 FIFA World Cup approaching and the league’s global profile higher than it has ever been, the next commissioner will face the monumental task of maintaining momentum while navigating a rapidly evolving media and technological landscape.

Meet the Three Finalists

The selection process reflects the league's desire to balance internal institutional knowledge with external expertise in media, finance, and sports management. Each of the three finalists brings a distinct background that could redefine the league’s strategic trajectory.

Larry Berg: The Ownership Perspective

As a co-owner of Los Angeles FC, Larry Berg is intimately familiar with the operational mechanics of an MLS franchise. His background in private equity and his success in building one of the league’s most commercially successful clubs make him a candidate who understands the bottom line. For stakeholders, Berg represents a continuity of the business-first model that defined the Garber era, while offering a fresh perspective on how to maximize franchise valuations.

Paraag Marathe: The Strategic Architect

Paraag Marathe, the president of 49ers Enterprises, is widely regarded as one of the most brilliant strategic minds in American professional sports. Beyond his work with the San Francisco 49ers, his involvement in international football—specifically his role at Leeds United—demonstrates a global understanding of the sport. Marathe’s expertise in data-driven decision-making and stadium development could be a massive asset as MLS continues to invest in infrastructure and international partnerships.

David Nathanson: The Media and Entertainment Veteran

Former Fox executive David Nathanson rounds out the list. His background is deeply rooted in the world of sports broadcasting and media rights. In an era where streaming deals, digital engagement, and content distribution are the lifeblood of professional leagues, Nathanson’s experience could prove invaluable. His previous work in negotiating high-stakes media deals aligns with the league's ambition to secure its next generation of television and digital rights.

The Legacy of Don Garber

Don Garber’s tenure as MLS commissioner is often cited as the most successful period of growth in the history of North American soccer. Since taking the helm in 1999, Garber oversaw the league’s expansion from 10 teams to 30, the implementation of the Designated Player rule, and the construction of soccer-specific stadiums across the country.

Whoever steps into this role will inherit a league that is no longer a fringe operation but a major player in the global sports entertainment ecosystem. The challenge will be to transition from a "growth-at-all-costs" phase to one of sustained profitability and international relevance.

What This Means for the Future of MLS

The choice of the next commissioner will signal the league's priorities for the next decade. If the board selects a candidate like Marathe, it may signal an aggressive move toward global integration and sophisticated data analytics. A choice like Berg might suggest a focus on deepening ownership satisfaction and maximizing domestic revenue. Meanwhile, a selection like Nathanson would likely prioritize the expansion of the league's media footprint and digital presence.

As the league enters the final stages of its selection process, the sports world will be watching closely. The impact of this decision will be felt not just in the front offices of the 30 MLS clubs, but throughout the entire landscape of American soccer. With the 2026 World Cup serving as a catalyst for growth, the new commissioner will have a unique opportunity to cement the league’s place as a top-tier global sports entity.